Warning: Table 'aryasi8x_db1.cache_page' doesn't exist query: SELECT data, created, headers, expire FROM cache_page WHERE cid = 'http://www.aryasamaj.org/newsite/node/474' in /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/database.mysql.inc on line 174

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/database.mysql.inc:174) in /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/bootstrap.inc on line 569

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/database.mysql.inc:174) in /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/bootstrap.inc on line 570

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/database.mysql.inc:174) in /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/bootstrap.inc on line 571

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/database.mysql.inc:174) in /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/bootstrap.inc on line 572
DAYANANDA AND VIVEKANANDA: a few points of difference | Aryasamaj
Skip navigation.
कृण्वन्तो विश्वमार्यम्

DAYANANDA AND VIVEKANANDA: a few points of difference

warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/database.mysql.inc:174) in /home/aryasi8x/public_html/newsite/includes/common.inc on line 141.

DAYANANDA AND VIVEKANANDA: a few points of difference

Dayananda gave four Vedas the highest importance. Vivekananda gave more importance to Udanishads and his teacher's (Ramkrishna's) thoughts and beliefs.

Dayananda taught and worshipped One Almighty Formless Omni-present God. Vivekananda practiced and taught worship of idol of goddess Kali and Sri Ramkrishna.

Dayananda believed that his teacher Swami Virajananda was a great extraordinary teacher of Sanskrit grammar, but he was a man, a mortal, and not God. Vivekanada believed that his teacher Ramkrishna was God himself.

Dayananda was against all sorts of anti-Vedic talks and superstition. Vivekananda made many compromises and accepted all forms of belief and worship.

Dayananda rejected incarnation theory. Vivekananda believed it and also tried to establish that his teacher was the latest and most perfect incarnation, greater than Sri Rama and Sri Krishna.

Dayananda was against British rule in India and he worked to make India free. Vivekananda contributed nothing significant in this matter.

Dayananda was pure Vedic personality. Vivekananda was total sum of so-called Hinduism.

Dayananda was believing in Vedic traitvad of eternally existing three fundamental entities: God, Soul and Matter. Vivekananda was monist (adwaitvadi of Shankaracharya's school) with a few modifications of his own. He tried to assimilate all philosophical currents, which made his philosophy very unclear.

Dayananda never visited any foreign country. Once Prox Max Muller proposed him to visit England, but he replied him that - "I wish to visit England, but still people of my country think that I am an atheist ! So let me make my countrymen realize that if I am an atheist, what sort of an atheist I am! Thereafter only, I may think to visit England." Vivekananda stayed in foreign lands for years.

Dayananda was against meat eating and shraddha of dead persons. Vivekananda believed in such things.

After taking Sannyas Dayananda never met his family and visited his birth place. This is not true in case of Vivekananda.

Dayananda was a man of fighting spirit throughout his life, up to his last breath - in words of Sri Aurobindo "an eternal worrier" and "a soldier of Light"! On other hand, if one very carefully go through Vivekananda' s letters and correspondence (patravali) he will definitely realize that frustration and disappointment is apparently seen in his last phase of life.

There are many such salient differences between these two great men. There are many similarities too.

= Bhavesh Merja

Sh bhavesh ji, Namaste, I

Sh bhavesh ji, Namaste, I may add one more important point - Swami Dayanand ji spent years togather in search of TRUTH, during which he left no known Yogi, Sadhu, Sanyasi, Tapasvi, Math & Mathadhish through out the land of Bharata, through jungles, mountains, rivers and their original resources i.e., Himalayas, Gangotri, Narmada, Kashi, Mathura etc., etc. till he found the TRUTH. He was a great Tapasvi, a great Yogi and a great BRAHMCHARI. I don't thing Swami Vivekanand did make such a great effort & search before he could arrive at the TRUTH.
Swami Dayanand ji had achieved the state of Samadhi which made him completely fearless, that's why he could take up the flag of TRUTH against worst of odds. We don't find such a marvellous and fearless personality in thosands of years except like Shiva, Rana Pratap & Guru Govind Singh ji. He was also a great Refomer Like the Adi Shankaracharya.
Dhanyawad
Anand

By the By who initiated

By the By who initiated Swami Vivekananda to Sanyasi order? This is important because at the time of taking sanyas one has to take so many volitions. Did Vivekanand took those volitions? But , I find his life was not in commensurate with the way a sanyasi should conduct himself. No doubt he was patriotic but he was anything but Sanyasi.

Namastey Bhavesh ji, Great

Namastey Bhavesh ji,

Great posting on this site.

I am highly grateful to you for the copy of the book by Swami Satya Prakash ji and translated/edited by you. I read the whole book from cover to cover in one sitting.

Swami Satya Prakash ji was an acknowledged Professor of Science and son of the Great Pt. Ganga Prasad Upadhyay. He alone could have written such a book, based on facts and presented in a highly logical manner.

Aditya